Background
Heterogeneity in disease onset pattern and slow progression makes it challenging to show a treatment effect in FSHD clinical trials. Fat-referenced, quantitative whole-body MRI biomarkers have demonstrated the ability to identify intermediately affected muscles with high likelihood of near-term progression in clinical trials but reports from natural history studies are scarce.
Aim
Describe one-year progression of fat-referenced MRI biomarkers in an FSHD natural history cohort and investigate if selecting intermediately affected muscles increases the progression rate of the biomarkers.
Methods
Whole-body Dixon MRI from the CTRN FSHD France (NCT04038138) Natural history study was analyzed using AMRA Researcher. 18 muscle groups were volumetrically analyzed bilaterally, and lean muscle volume (LMV), muscle fat fraction (MFF), and muscle fat infiltration (MFI) were quantified. Muscles were classified at baseline as Normal Appearing (MFI<10% & MFF<50%), Intermediate (MFI>10% & MFF<50%), or End-Stage (MFF>50%). Measurements from individual muscles were combined into composites. Responsiveness was assessed using standardized response mean (SRM).
Results
56 patients were included with age, mean(SD), 50.1(12.2) years, Clinical Severity Score, median[min,max], 6[2,9]. One year progression in whole-body composite LMV/MFF/MFI (mean±SE, (SRM)) was -2.33±0.47%, (-0.66) / 0.93±0.16pp, (0.77) / 0.21±0.06 pp, (0.46). Progression in intermediate muscles was -4.10±0.67%, (-0.86) / 1.89±0.33pp, (0.8) / 0.37±0.11pp, (0.47), and -1.59±0.49%, (-0.43) / 0.58±0.12pp, (0.64) / 0.19±0.06pp, (0.43), in normal appearing muscles. Progression in intermediate muscle composites (for LMV and MFF) was significantly higher compared to composites of either normal appearing muscles or all muscles (p<0.01).
Conclusion
This study showed that whole-body composites of intermediate muscles (1) demonstrated the highest progression rate, validating the methods performance in identifying fast-progressing muscles, (2) reduces the impact of disease heterogeneity as a confounding factor in describing progression. This makes it a highly responsive biomarker for monitoring of disease progression (SRM=0.86) in a slowly progressing, heterogenous diseases such as FSHD.